Pages

Showing posts with label Film. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Film. Show all posts

Thursday, July 05, 2012

“The Killing” and God and Suffering

Where is God when life falls apart?

That’s what “Mitch” Larsen wants to know, too.

Now that I’ve started in on Season 1 of AMC’s The Killing, Netflix can’t send the DVDs fast enough. The series weaves together three story lines around a single murder: the suspects, the detectives, and the victim's grieving family.

It’s rare for this genre to give such heart-rending attention to a murder victim’s survivors. In one scene, the grieving mother, “Mitch” Larsen, joins her husband, Stanley, at the Catholic church to plan the funeral. The scene begins with the mother taking a long look at the crucifix while her husband and the priest plan the service. The camera shows Mitch taking in Christ's wounds--the nails in hands and feet, the wound from the spear, the pricks of a crown of thorns pressed into his scalp. As the meeting wraps up, the priest offers some canned reassurance that their daughter is with God. Mitch absorbs this for a moment and then rejects it: "Where was God when my daughter was scared and alone?" The priest awkwardly stares at the anguished mom, apparently caught by surprise at this age-old question. The scene ends as husband and wife walk away one way and the priest another.

Though I’m a fan of the show, it’s too bad the writers staged a priestly character who was nothing more than a two-dimensional foil for Mitch’s heart-broken anger. I doubt a church leader of his gray-headed experience would have been so trite with his “comfort” and so befuddled with a mother’s cries.

But even if the TV show’s priest didn’t have a word of comfort for her, the writers supplied the Christian answer to her questions. It was at the start of the scene, as Mitch scanned the symbol of our faith's central story: the crucifixion.

Christianity teaches that God actually entered in to our broken world in order to redeem it. Here’s how the late John Stott put it in his marvelous book, The Cross of Christ:
I could never myself believe in God, if it were not for the cross….In the real world of pain, how could one worship a God who was immune to it? I have entered many Buddhist temples in different Asian countries and stood respectfully before the statue of the Buddha, his legs crossed, arms folded, eyes closed, the ghost of a smile playing round his mouth, a remote look on his face, detached from the agonies of the world. But each time after a while I have had to turn away. And in imagination I have turned instead to that lonely, twisted, tortured figure on the cross, nails through hands and feet, back lacerated, limbs wrenched, brow bleeding from thorn-pricks, mouth dry and intolerably thirsty, plunged in Godforsaken darkness. That is the God for me! He laid aside his immunity to pain. He entered our world of flesh and blood, tears and death. He suffered for us. Our sufferings become more manageable in the light of his. There is still a question mark against human suffering, but over it we boldly stamp another mark, the cross that symbolizes divine suffering.
Beautiful!

In light of that truth, there’s a better editing for the above scene from The Killing. How about this:


Meditating on “Wounded Love and Bleeding Mercy” is the only way forward when life falls apart.


Selah.

Friday, January 13, 2012

Closer to Scorsese's "Silence"

Jesuit priest Tim Byron reports that we're getting closer to Martin Scorsese's film adaptation of Shusaku Endo's Silence. The acclaimed director's love of the book comes through his forward to a recent edition:

How do you tell the story of Christian faith? The difficulty, the crisis, of believing? How do you describe the struggle? ... [Shusaku Endo] understood the conflict of faith, the necessity of belief fighting the voice of experience. The voice that always urges the faithful - the questioning faithful - to adapt their beliefs to the world they inhabit, their culture...That's a paradox, and it can be an extremely painful one: on the face of it, believing and questioning are antithetical. Yet I believe that they go hand in hand. One nourishes the other. Questioning may lead to great loneliness, but if it co-exists with faith - true faith, abiding faith - it can end in the most joyful sense of communion. It's this painful, paradoxical passage - from certainty to doubt to loneliness to communion - that Endo understands so well, and renders so clearly, carefully and beautifully in Silence.

I liked Endo's Silence, but I liked The Samurai better, and wrote about it here. I've been waiting for news on Silence since 2006, when I posted this:

What will the acclaimed director focus on from Endo's novel? What concerns me is what will be done with the priest's spiritual struggles and with the challenges from his tormentors. The priest in the novel often asks himself about the silence of God in the face of such intense suffering on the part of faithful Christians. And the tormentors often remind the priest that the Japanese have their own religion (Buddhism) and the Christian faith he is trying to transplant in that foreign soil will never survive. The Japanese officials, in fact, consider Christianity just one more Western characteristic they are trying to expel from their islands.

Could it be that it's this theme that has captured the attention of the director and screenwriter: the conviction that Christianity is part of "Western culture" that shouldn't be imposed on other cultures? Never mind that it's this conviction that led 17th century Japanese magistrates to devise the most inhumane of tortures for their own Japanese citizens who embraced Christianity.

Will the magistrates become "the voice of reason" in this film adaptation of the novel? Will the film convey the futility of missionaries like this priest who bring Christianity to other cultures only to bring trouble to the people who embrace it? It would certainly fit the spirit of the age: To many, Christianity is looked upon as a "Western religion"--even an "American religion"--that shouldn't be transplanted to other cultures. In reality, Christianity is a universal faith that transcends passports, flags, and national customs. Far from being "Western" or "American," culturally-speaking, Christianity actually sprang from a Jewish messianic movement in first-century Jersusalem under Roman occupation. It spread from there south, east, west, and--for our interests in America--it also spread north into what is now Europe and the British isles to take root in Anglo-Saxon soil and from there made its way to America. In other words, cultures now considered "Western" and specifically "American" were recipients of missionary outreach long, long before they became supporters of missionary outreach.

More here.

 

Sunday, July 25, 2010

The Latest Post from Film and Theology: Inception

Here’s an interesting use of Inception to raise conversation about the gospel. There are so many poor ways that people do this with film—usually by grasping one thin concept and pulling it out of the film’s context to somehow make an analogy to the gospel. James Harleman does a good job keeping the point he’s drawn from the film within the context of the film and commenting on it from the perspective of the gospel. Here’s his take on Inception:

You can find more commentary at Cinemagogue.

Wednesday, May 14, 2008

So Many Movies . . . So Little Time

Prince Caspian opens this Friday. In the 7-book Narnia series, Reepicheep is one of my favorite characters. In the film he'll be voiced by Eddie Izzard. Reep didn't make it in any of the trailers so far:



Of course, the Indiana Jones flick opens next weekend:



And it was a kick to see Iron Man this past weekend:

Friday, April 04, 2008

Into the Wild

Just saw Sean Penn's directorial debut, Into the Wild. Oh man.
"Happiness is only real when shared."

"To call each thing by its right name . . . by its right name."
Astonishing. And, no, I know none of those lines make sense unless you've seen it.

So what are you waiting for?

Tuesday, December 04, 2007

Articles For Navigating The Golden Compass

I wrote about the upcoming film adaptation of The Golden Compass last week. You can send the post as an e-mail by clicking here.

Since then, I've found some helpful articles that reinforce some of the things I was saying, as well as providing more details. You'll find the following useful:

In "The Devil's Party," Alan Jacobs wrote, "Whichever party readers support in the ancient contest between God and Satan, they will be disappointed to see how often, in The Amber Spyglass, the tale’s momentum is interrupted by polemic. Pullman’s anti-theistic scolding consorts poorly with his prodigious skills as a storyteller. In imagination and narrative drive, he has few peers among current novelists. For such gifts to be thrust into the service of a reductive and contemptuous ideology is very nearly a tragedy."

In "An Almost Christian Fantasy," Daniel P. Moloney supplies a helpful recap of the three books, and critiques Pullman's effort to set up an alternative to the Christian storyline of Creation, Fall, Sin, Death, and Heaven-Hell.

Albert Mohler has read the books and is one of the first reviewers to see the film. In his briefing, he explains some of the misunderstandings that Pullman has of Christianity--not the least is Pullman's mistaken idea that Original Sin is sexual intercourse. In the end, he says, "Philip Pullman has an agenda, but so do we. Our agenda is the Gospel of Christ -- a message infinitely more powerful than that of The Golden Compass. Pullman's worldview of unrestricted human autonomy would be nightmarish if ever achieved. His story promises liberation but would enslave human beings to themselves and destroy all transcendent value. The biblical story of the Fall is true, after all, and our only rescue is through the Gospel of Jesus Christ. The curse of sin was not reversed by adolescents playing at sex in a garden, but by the Son of God shedding His blood on a cross."

At ChristianityToday.com, film critic Peter Chattaway introduces us to Tony Watkins, author of Dark Matter, a useful book that analyzes the trilogy from a Christian framework. Also, film critic Jeffrey Overstreet provides good answers to some common questions on the film.

Locally, Sara Stevenson wrote in the Statesman that "the anti-Christian message gets in the way of a good story." While reading the trilogy with her book club, she said he enjoyed the first book (The Golden Compass), but as she read the second book she said, "My defense of Pullman thinned." By the third book, "I found myself getting angry with the author because his anti-Church comments began to get in the way of a great story."

And in "How Hollywood Saved God," Hanna Rosin details how the nervous New Line studio has stripped most of Pullman's most subversive themes in order to protect their $180 million investment.

Saturday, November 24, 2007

Navigating The Golden Compass

“So, there is a God, but he is a liar and he’s mortal.”

It’s significant that a journalist noticed this notation on Philip Pullman's writing desk because it’s the thrust of his three-volume work, His Dark Materials (HDM). New Line Cinema has spent $180 million to bring the first book of Pullman’s trilogy to screen. The Golden Compass opens December 7.

New Line is the studio that brought us The Lord of the Rings trilogy, and clearly New Line is hoping it has another Rings-style hit on its hands. They might, what with the big stars, the astonishing special effects, and the fact that the film is based on award-winning children’s books that have served as Scholastic study material in some middle schools.

But here’s the thing: while the Christian worldview infuses the Rings trilogy, it is opposition to the Christian worldview that you find in Pullman’s trilogy.

So, what should parents do? And what should culturally-savvy Christians do about this much-discussed project? That’s the subject of this post.

What Should Parents Do

The books portray such an avid and astonishing hostility to Christianity that I’m baffled anyone would recommend the material for kids.

I’ve read the trilogy, and its popularity is no surprise. Despite my contention that the quality of the story-telling meanders away in the closing chapters of the third book, it’s an intriguing work. Pullman employs interesting literary devices, not the least of which is the characters’ “daemons”— no, not “demons” but the characters’ souls, external to the body and in animal form. Warrior polar bears, flying zeppelins, a precocious 12-year-old protagonist with a destiny to fulfill, special tools like a knife that cuts openings into other worlds, the kindness of common people contrasted with the driven selfishness of the powerful, spectres that suck life from their victims, and a complicated mystery to unravel--it all makes for an engaging read.

But, as Pullman has accurately said, his books are about “killing God” (sample) and marginalizing "organised religion of whatever sort" (sample).

Of course, with 180 million of New Line’s dollars at stake, the closer we get to the opening weekend of The Golden Compass the more “toned down” Pullman has become from previous interviews. And I doubt the first film in the series will delve too deeply into these subjects.

But that’s just for now. Director Chris Weitz says he plans to stay true to the books’ anti-religious elements should New Line let him put the other books to film. Astonishingly, he said that he’s had to be “clever about it” until he builds an audience for “the overt stating of some of the themes in The Golden Compass.” But he assures Pullman fans:
Whereas The Golden Compass had to be introduced to the public carefully, the religious themes in the second and third books can't be minimized without destroying the spirit of these books. . . . I will not be involved with any ‘watering down’ of books two and three, since what I have been working towards the whole time in the first film is to be able to deliver on the second and third films. (Link.)
I don’t know whether New Line will let Weitz deliver on his promises. (This entertaining commentary says they won’t.) But if his subsequent films are able to stay true to the books, this won’t be a movie series for the kids.

What Culturally-Savvy Christians Should Do

The New Yorker is probably right, though, that more adults have read Pullman’s trilogy than kids. And I’m ready to have a conversation with grown-ups about the Oxford author’s rich story-telling and complex themes.

Let’s talk about Pullman’s “daemons”: What is he saying by portraying souls as animal characters that are the opposite sex of the person (except in the case of homosexuals), daemons that become fixed into one unchangeable form once a person becomes an adult? Let’s talk about Dust. Let’s talk about Pullman’s “god”: Does Pullman actually conceive of angels and “god” as highly-developed creatures in the continuing evolution from unconsciousness to higher consciousness? Or is “god’s” death a metaphor for Pullman’s wish to see the Christian conception of God go away? What led to Pullman’s pull-no-punches hostility to organized religion? I mean, I'll sadly grant that church history has had shameful moments where leaders have been as sinister as every single churchman in HDM, but there’s not a single counterbalancing religiously-admirable character in the trilogy’s vast cast. So, what led to Pullman’s hostility, and why has he found an audience? Is his view of death as mere annihilation of consciousness as satisfying as he puts it in the mouth of one of his characters freed from “hell”? Is his understanding of the biblical Fall accurate, and is his alternate “Fall” at the end of the series as good for the world as he envisions? As the films come out, what do Pullman fans like and dislike about the translation from books to film?

Fodder for a lot of late-night conversations.

Among grown-ups.

Send this post to a friend.


The Trailer

Monday, September 03, 2007

300: My Review's Already Written

Despite all the raves, I didn't think I'd be getting to the theater to see 300, so I put it on my Netflix list. It arrived last week. I was going to write about my reaction to the film, but this blogger has already said what I would say. Read the Steven Pressfield book, Gates of Fire, instead.

Now, The Lives of Others, that's a film worth seeing. Mind the R-rating, but a fine film that explores the question, "Can a person change, do the right thing, and become a 'good man'?" The closing line is deliberate: "It's for me."

Saturday, July 28, 2007

Ned Flanders and His THEMs

On the opening weekend of The Simpsons Movie, Christianity Today has re-issued their February 2001 article, "Blessed Ned of Springfield." It's an adaptation from Mark Pinsky's book, The Gospel According to the Simpsons: The Spiritual Life of America's Most Animated Family.

The article will introduce you to Ned Flanders, television's most well-rounded evangelical character. But it was Pinsky's closing comments that really caught my attention. I hope we're all like the neighbors he has. Ned Flanders can teach us a few things about relating to our THEMs:

Stripped of their comedic excess and hyperbole, how fairly do Ned and his family represent evangelical Christianity to the world? As an observant Jew raised in a Northeastern suburb, I may not be the best judge. Or maybe I am. For the past five years, I have reported on the evangelical movement—locally and nationally—for The Orlando Sentinel newspaper. More to the point, fate and my central Florida suburb have put me into close contact with a family I see as the Flanders family in real life. Until I raised the issue with them, they had no basis for comparison; they didn't watch the show or allow their children to watch it.

Dan and Lorraine Hardaway are an attractive, college-educated couple in their late 30s. Each experienced some degree of dysfunction in their early lives before turning to Jesus. Dan, who has reddish blond hair and blue eyes, works full time for a Christian outreach organization based in Orlando. Lorraine, whose auburn hair frames a face brightened by a toothy grin, is a stay-at-home mom. Their four children, who range in age from 6 to 14, are as good-natured as Rod and Todd Flanders but considerably more worldly. The Hardaways belong to a nondenominational, evangelical megachurch and a small Bible-study group. They sing in the choir and listen to a contemporary Christian radio station in their cars and at home, and hold conservative beliefs on social issues, although they disagree with some aspects of the Christian Right. For the most part, they grapple with the same things our family does: balancing their stretched budget and busy schedules, deciding what television show or computer game is appropriate for the kids. Like their neighbors, they made an accommodation with Beanie Babies, PokÉmon, and, after much soul-searching and consultation with Christian friends, the Harry Potter books. With their agreement, I use the family as a source, a sounding board, and a pipeline to ground-level believers for my newspaper reporting.

Are the Hardaways typical of evangelical Christians, as typical as the Flanders family? It's hard to say. We have come to know them pretty well in recent years. Our children attend the same public elementary school and the same scout troops at the school, and often attend the same birthday parties, which means we are often in and out of each other's houses. They are sophisticated and generally open-minded, and never press their religious or political views on us or on our children. It is apparent, though, that they draw strength from their Christian faith, which they try to apply to every aspect of their lives. I met them before I started watching The Simpsons, but I cannot watch the Flanders family without thinking of the Hardaways.

I showed them an early draft of this essay, loaned them some tapes from the series and asked them what they thought. "All in all, it would be flattering to be associated with Ned Flanders, based on what I know about the person and how he lives out his faith," Dan says. "There's an element of unconditional love in his life that accurately portrays Christianity." Some Christians might be put off by some of the idiosyncrasies associated with the character, like "nerdy behavior," he added.

Lorraine agreed . . . . "How else are people going to see Jesus' teachings lived out unless they see them in our lives?" she says. "It's very important that we're part of the world, that others can see the difference he's made and the truth we believe he taught and shared."

Saturday, March 31, 2007

Disappointed with "Children of Men"

I've been looking forward to the DVD release of "Children of Men" since I didn't see the theater release.

What a let-down.

The P.D. James novel was a good read: set in Britain in the year 2021, when fertility has mysteriously faded and the world hasn't had a child born for 18 years. As the last generation to be born, those in their 20s have been spoiled to the point of becoming unruly, even vicious and murderous. The government mandates fertility testing, but hope has all but faded, and the citizens have accepted a dictatorship in return for stability and pleasure in the remaining years of human existence. In order to manage England's fading resources, immigration is strictly managed, people are shipped off for any disruption to the government's plans, and old people are euthanized through the advertised services of the "Quietus."

(Spoiler alert: If you don't want to know what happens in the novel and the film, stop reading)

In the James novel, the lead male character, Theo, slowly discovers the inhumanity of the dictatorship that his country has accepted. He discovers this through his connection with a group of five ordinary Christians who call themselves "the Five Fishes" (an ancient symbol of Christianity). Though hopelessly ordinary, the little band tries to make their concerns known, only to be falsely accused by the government of being a terrorist organization. The Five Fishes approach Theo because of his connection to the dictator (they are cousins). In his time with the group, he discovers the truth about the hellish prison island that people are shipped to, and he watches in horror as the wife of an old friend of his participates in the "Quietus," whereby drugged seniors are chained to boats that are then sunk at sea.

And then he makes the most stunning discovery of all: Julian, the leader of the Fishes, is pregnant. The government didn't bother to test her (nor the father), since both had deformations that the government would not have found desirable. There's something wonderfully symbolic of Julian's delivery in a stable, like another child of hope born in a stable 2000 years ago.

As I said, a good read.

So, what happened to the story as it got turned into a film? An incomprehensible mess.

Xan, the dictator, makes a cameo appearance in the film, but his advantageous connection to Theo is never exploited. In the film, Julian is Theo's ex-wife, and she's had a long history of leading the Fishes--which in the film is clearly not a band of ordinary Christian citizens but rather a resistance band of violent, foul-mouthed fighters who are armed to the teeth and like to blow things up. We're never told why they like to blow things up, and they come across as a bunch of hardened anarchists. In fact, in a mad power play among the Fishes, Julian is assassinated by some of the others. Huh?

Yes, there's a pregnant woman in the film: not Julian but an immigrant named Kee who couldn't say which of her many "wankers" is really the father. Theo and Kee run for their lives along with the midwife Julian had enlisted to help with the delivery. Along the way, this midwife mumbles an amalgamation of Eastern chants and something that sort of sounds like Christian prayers. That's a close as we get to anything like the faith convictions of P.D. James' Christian characters.

There's the Quietus, too, and in the film it lives up to its name: a sort of "euthanasia home kit" where you can quietly take your own life. Theo takes Kee and the midwife to the country home of an older couple whose friendship he has enjoyed over the years. This is one of the more bizarre concoctions of the film: Michael Caine plays this old pot-smoking hippie: every time he's in a scene, there's a soundtrack of old sixties music playing. Did the film makers ever consider that if the film is set in the year 2021, Caine's senior adult character would have been in preschool during the 60s? Well, the Fishes find the runaways anyway, and as the anarchists close in, Theo and the midwife and the mother-to-be escape while the old man euthanizes his infirm wife with their little Quietus kit.

The film has won a bunch of awards for its cinematography, and deservedly so. In several scenes, a single camera captures all the action without cutting away, and this clearly took some planning. But this is one of the most ham-fisted adaptations of a book that I've seen in a long time. If you haven't seen it, drop it from your Netflix queue and read the book instead.

Saturday, March 24, 2007

Reaction to Endo's "The Samurai"

I was introduced to Japanese author Shusaku Endo after reading that Martin Scorsese was preparing to direct a film adaptation of Endo's book, Silence. My reaction to that news and Endo's book can be found here.

The Samurai is the second book of Endo's I've read, and I liked it better than Silence. It's the story of four Japanese envoys sent with Spanish sailors and a Franciscan missionary to open trade negotiations with 17th-century Spain. While away on their four-year journey, the sentiments among Japan's leaders change. Doors to any connection with outsiders close and persecution of missionaries and Japanese Christians begins. The envoys, as symbols of an earlier effort to open doors to Spanish trade and missionary work, suffer the consequences of the new Japanese policies they return into.

The story focuses in particular upon two men: an ambitious missionary named Valesco, and a samurai named Rokuemon Hasekura who served as one of the envoys. The novel is a fictional speculation on the events surrounding actual historical figures. The book was widely acclaimed when it was released in 1980, and received Japan's most coveted literary award.

I was moved by the slow change in the missionary's character so that his raw and sinful ambition finally gave way to the humility of his final confession. It was also engaging to see the slow conversion of the samurai. From an insincere compliance to baptism, Hasekura finally embraces the Lord who will not abandon him.

In fact, it's noteworthy that Endo's working title for this novel was A Man Who Met a King, according to a postscript by the translator:

That title is most appropriate, for the Hasekura of both fact and fiction had the opportunity to come face to face with several kings of the earth. These meetings, however, all proved to be hollow, defeating. Hasekura and his warrior comrades are bested in the arena of the flesh and return to Japan humiliated and unsuccessful. But when Hasekura stands before an abyss of despair and likely death, he encounters yet another King, one who seeks only to salve his wounds, one who has also been 'despised and rejected of men.' It is when Hasekura meets and embraces this pathetic King that his own sorrows become endurable.
The translator goes on to point out in the postscript that this novel was Endo's most autobiographical, and Hasekura's slow arrival at faith in Christ paralleled Endo's own faith journey as well.

A fascinating story about a part of history I had never studied, and about trials to faith I have never experienced.

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Recommended Film: "Merry Christmas" (Joyeux Noel)



Have you seen “Merry Christmas” (Joyeux Noel). It was nominated for a 2006 Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film. If you don't like the audio/video quality of the trailer above, you can see a clearer version here.

It's inspired by the true story from the First World War, when something fascinating took place on Christmas Eve 1914. As Ravi Zacharias tells it:

In the midst of an uneasy silence of the guns at night, suddenly a lone voice began to sing a Christmas carol. Irresistibly, another voice joined in, and before one knew it, there was a wave of music because of Bethlehem, cascading across enemy lines, as both sides joined in reading the same script. The story of the babe in a manger, the Prince of Peace, was able to bring communion between warring factions, even for a few hours. This is how a songwriter tells that story. Unfortunately, I can quote only a few stanzas here:

Oh, my name is Francis Tolliver,
I come from Liverpool.
Two years ago the war was waiting
For me after school,
From Belgium and to Flanders,
Germany to here,
I fought for King and country I love dear.

'Twas Christmas in the trenches
And the frost so bitter hung,
The frozen fields of France were still,
No sounds of peace were sung.
Our families back in England
Were toasting us that day,
Their brave and glorious lads so far away

I was lying with me mess-mates
On the cold and rocky ground,
When across the lines of battle came
A most peculiar sound.
Says I, "Now listen up, me boys,"
Each soldier strained to hear
As one young German voice rang out so clear.

"He's singing very well, you know,"
My partner says to me.
Soon one by one each German voice
joined in the harmony.
The canons rested silent
And the gas cloud rolled no more,
As Christmas brought us respite from the war.

As soon as they were finished
And a reverent pause was spent,
"God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen"
Struck up some lads from Kent.
The next they sang was "Stille Nacht,"
"Tis 'Silent Night,' " says I,
And in two tongues one song filled up the sky.
The film is PG-13 for what the MPAA calls "some war violence and a brief scene of sexuality/nudity." So, keep that in mind. But good film-making here, and a worthwhile story. If you've seen it, or if you decide to, tell me what you think.

Friday, November 24, 2006

Trailer for "The Nativity Story"

"The Nativity Story" opens December 1. Southern Baptist Theological Seminary president Albert Mohler calls it "in season and on message."

It stars Keisha Castle-Hughes (Oscar nominee for Whale Rider), and it was written by Mike Rich (Radio, The Rookie) and directed by Catherine Hardwicke (Thirteen). Costing more than $65 million to make and market, "Nativity" is one of the biggest and most expensive biblical-themed releases from a major media company. The film, recounting Mary and Joseph's journey to Bethlehem, will open on 2,700 screens. There’s an interesting article here about the growing interest in films respectful of the Christian faith. Here's the trailer:

Monday, October 30, 2006

What Will Scorsese Do with "Silence"?

Martin Scorsese is working on an adaptation of Silence, a novel by the late Japanese author Shusaku Endo (1923-1996) who also wrote the screenplay for the 1971 Japanese film Chinmoku (Silence). Endo was a Christian and Silence tracks the struggles of a Portugese Jesuit called to Japan during a season of severe persecution designed to obliterate Christianity. Jay Cocks (who wrote the screenplay for Scorsese's Gangs of New York) is the screenwriter, and production is due to begin in the summer of 2007.

What drew Scorsese to this project, and what will he do with the material? Worthwhile questions, considering that this was the director behind the camera for the 1988 film The Last Temptation of Christ, and the director who turned the murderer in the 1991 remake of Cape Fear into a Pentecostal Christian (in reaction--some say--to the way Christians attacked his Last Temptation film).

What will the acclaimed director focus on from Endo's novel? What concerns me is what will be done with the priest's spiritual struggles and with the challenges from his tormentors. The priest in the novel often asks himself about the silence of God in the face of such intense suffering on the part of faithful Christians. And the tormentors often remind the priest that the Japanese have their own religion (Buddhism) and the Christian faith he is trying to transplant in that foreign soil will never survive. The Japanese officials, in fact, consider Christianity just one more Western characteristic they are trying to expel from their islands.

Could it be that it's this theme that has captured the attention of the director and screenwriter: the conviction that Christianity is part of "Western culture" that shouldn't be imposed on other cultures? Never mind that it's this conviction that led 17th century Japanese magistrates to devise the most inhuman of tortures for their own Japanese citizens who embraced Christianity.
Will the magistrates become "the voice of reason" in this film adaptation of the novel? Will the film convey the futility of missionaries like this priest who bring Christianity to other cultures only to bring trouble to the people who embrace it? It would certainly fit the spirit of the age: to many, Christianity is looked upon as a "Western religion"--even an "American religion"--that shouldn't be transplanted to other cultures. In reality, Christianity is a universal faith that transcends passports, flags, and national customs. Far from being "Western" or "American," culturally-speaking, Christianity actually sprang from a Jewish messianic movement in first-century Jersusalem under Roman occupation. It spread from there south, east, west, and--for our interests in America--it also spread north into what is now Europe and the British isles to take root in Anglo-Saxon soil and from there made its way to America. In other words, cultures now considered "Western" and specifically "American" were recipients of missionary outreach long, long before they became supporters of missionary outreach.

So, I'm waiting to see how Jay Cocks and Martin Scorsese deal with this theme in Endo's novel. It would be ironic if the film looked sympathetically upon the novel's characters who justify their inhumane torture of Japanese Christians on the premise that a "Western" religion had no place in Japanese culture.

Hat Tip to Jeffrey Overstreet, who announced the upcoming film adaptation of Endo's novel in his review of Scorsese's current film, The Departed. Overstreet wrote:

Shazuko Endo’s Silence . . . gives Scorsese the richest, most profound source material he's ever had to work with. Let's hope that he finds himself more inspired by the passion of the missionary than by the malevolence of the devils who try to discourage him.

Wednesday, October 25, 2006

Our "Hillcrest Connection" to an Austin Film Festival Winner

Diane and I got a chance to see "Chalk" at the Austin Film Festival last night. Katie Brock, a vocalist in our Hillcrest Praise Band, has a role as a math teacher. They mis-spelled her name on the credits (to keep you humble, Katie!), but it was still fun to see her up on the big screen!

The film is a "mocumentary" in the style of "The Office" on NBC. Instead of tracking the hapless happennings of a sales force in a paper supply company, though, "Chalk" follows four green teachers in their struggles.

"Chalk" was one of the few locally-produced films screened at the Austin Film Festival. It was written by Mike Akel (who also directed), and Chris Mass. Both have had experience as teachers in area high schools (Travis and Lanier).

I hear that the film has been picked up by a major distributor, and deservedly so. The four actors who play the key roles do a great job, and the pace and comic timing is nearly perfect.

To see the trailer, click here. To read an article from the Austin Chronicle, click here.

Monday, July 31, 2006

A Good Conversation About a Lame Movie

What happens when a fourth generation Jewish atheist accepts a pastor's invitation to join him to watch and discuss The Da Vinci Code? Find out in Joel Stein's column, Doing 'Da Vinci' with the pastor dude. "I think God's doing something in your life," Stein reports as the pastor's words, "And I'm glad to be a small part of it."