Pages

Showing posts with label Lost. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lost. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 02, 2010

A Heapin’ Helpin’ of Lost Commentary

I’ve collected some of the reactions to Lost since the season finale May 23. Time to offload them in a blog post. If you’re a Lost fan, you should check these out. (For all my posts on Lost, click here.)


The season finale was 'a cop-out' and 'a turn for the worse,' says author and 'Lost' guru Chris Seay. But he suggests 4 important lessons we can learn from the series anyway:

1) We are all lost

2) Fictional friends matter

3) Like Jack, I have a calling

4) The Bible's heaven beats Lost's




Michael Patton hated the finale with all the vitriol of a jilted fan, but Tyler Charles at CT’s Books and Culture liked it.


Hank Stuever drew the same conclusion I did: The whole series (not just the “flash sideways” plot device of Season Six) was about a purgatory-ish place:

People in "Lost" died multiple times in a lot of ways. Jack's exit in the final minutes of "Lost" was the death that got him to heaven, but the 815 crash was the death that got him busy on what he was meant to do. That's why the finale takes Jack back to that same bamboo field -- where he snapped awake in 2004 (dead, but not technically) and where, now that he is fully cognizant of all that has happened (and un-happened), he lays down and experiences a final peace. His work is done.

I know some hardcore fans don't want to believe it was purgatory all along, perhaps because they worked so hard to decipher "Lost's" layers of pointless mythology and whatnot. This is not an "it was all a dream" ending. It was about another realm that is like a dream, which explains why everything had to be so frustrating, complicated -- like a dream where you can't solve a problem.

But not a dream. An actual place -- a purgatory. Or for people who hate that word, an in-between. You don't go there simply because your soul is stuck. You go there because you're needed.

Mind you: The theology is disappointing, but I think this is what the authors were trying to say. Terry Mattingly, who linked to the Stuever piece, called it “Purgatory Lite”


Megan Basham says it was a “squandered opportunity.”


Al Hsu explains what 'Lost' taught us about dying well: “At the end of the day, and at the end of our lives, we're not going to care if we understood how the Dharma Initiative fit into the epic confrontation between Jacob and the Man in Black. But we're going to want assurance that we will see our loved ones again, and that our eternal destiny is secure.”


Joe Carter regarded it as “lazy storytelling.” He has a point:

The creators had no idea what they were doing—at all. They kept piling up plot points that made the show intriguing yet they knew something we didn’t: that there would not be a payoff to any of them because the creators themselves didn’t create them with a purpose.

What is really frustrating—and reinforces just how not-smart Cuse and Lindelof are—is that they didn’t even have to know where the story went. The fans had created the necessary theories to tie it all together. All they had to do was read the internet, pick out the best theory, and then make that the way Lost ends. They would have looked like geniuses. Now, they have simply revealed themselves as posers.



For “Exhibit #3,754 in the Case of the Clueless Creators,” Carter presents: “Sayid. The entire series they showed him, from childhood to the flash sideways, motivated to act because of his one-true-love, Nadia. Yet what happens in The End? He spends eternity in heaven with his summer fling Shannon.”


The “33 Things” feature at the Evangelical Outpost linked to “A heapin’ helpin’ of Lost’s loose ends” and “How Lost should have ended.”


Yes, don’t miss that: You should check out “How Lost should have ended.”


I’ve enjoyed The Late Greats’ weekly “One Song Lost” recap while Lost was running. Here’s the last, from Chanticleer.


Film and Theology at The Resurgence had some good insights. Watch it here:

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Lost: What It All Meant

I consider this the definitive commentary on Lost. David Letterman from Monday night: “It turned out that the end—you all know the end—it turned that everybody was dead and the last six years has just been a TV show.”

Monday, May 24, 2010

Lost: “I See Dead People”

Of all the shoutouts the Lost creators have made to their favorite influences, who woulda thought their biggest influence would have been M. Night Shyamalan?

The series finale of Lost revealed that all the characters we’ve followed for the last six years were ghosts unwilling to acknowledge that fact and move on.

In other words, the Sixth Season was The Sixth Sense.

Not to complain. The Sixth Sense is the one flick Shyamalan has done that’s worked for me, and the Lost creators did a great job applying the plot device from that film to their series finale.

It was fitting for Jack to be the last of the cast to “let go” and accept the truth, as he did in the exchange with the ghost of his father:

Jack: You died.

Christian: Yes, I did.

Jack: Then how are you here right now.

Christian: How are you here?

Jack: (realization comes to him) I died too.

As Jack slowly came to peace with this truth, the story—and Jack’s eye—closed as it opened six seasons ago. (With Vincent by his side. *sniff*)

Turns out the Lost island was a kind of Purgatory, as many fans have insisted through the seasons. Ben Linus, for example, doesn’t go into the church with the other ghosts because, as he explains to Locke, he “still has some things to work out” so he’ll “be here a while.” But his sincere apology and Locke’s offer of forgiveness matter to him “far more than I can say.”

As the ghosts gained insight into their experience, we saw them working to help their friends come to terms with the truth as well. (A nice touch to bring back Season One’s original cast members, Boone and Shannon, for that work.)

Of course, some ghosts were “not ready yet,” as Daniel Faraday/Widmore’s mother said of her son. (Or was it his mother who was not ready to let him go? Hmm…) But, as Hurley said to Boone after Sayid finally got it: “It takes as long as it takes.”

Fans will probably spend the next few days deciding whether The Sixth Sense plot device makes sense of all they’ve shared with the characters:

  • The polar bears—and those dang polar bear cages…
  • The Dharma Initiative…
  • Mr. Eko’s Virgin Mary smuggling scheme…
  • The whole thing with Michael and Walt and the Others…
  • The island traveling through time…
  • And—most important to me—the whole Jacob/Man-in-Black mythology…

What was it all for? In the end, it “doesn’t matter,” as Desmond tried to tell Jack while he was still unwilling to let it all go. “This is a place you all made together,” Christian tells his son, “To remember. And to let go.” In other words, the Island was all about moving on.

Moving on where, as Jack asks in the closing minutes? “Let’s go find out,” said Christian Shepherd, standing with his son next to his coffin—their coffin…our coffin—in a room stuffed with religious imagery from Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, Islam, and Judaism.

Some will take this to mean that the Lost creators are implying that all these religious traditions are basically saying the same thing about our mortality. If so, that would be an unsatisfactory conclusion.

But I took it to mean that all these religious traditions are basically addressing the same concerns—which is, of course, true. How they tell the living to prepare for death—now that’s where we differ. And I’m taking my guidance from One who’s entered into death and has conquered it for me.

So, the show was about moving on, then, but moving on together. “Live together or die alone” has been the show’s recurring theme. In the end, the show was also about dying together—or, to be more precise, processing that reality together.

Kudos.

Saturday, May 22, 2010

“What I find is that Lost occupies that level of conversation”

ET’s Jeff Jensen, in an interview with CT, says the themes in Lost can begin spiritual conversation:

I grew up in a Christian culture. My primary mandate as a Christian is to evangelize and convert people to Christianity. What I find in my life is when I talk to people who are not religious at all, the conversation can't begin with, "Meet my friend Jesus." These are people who don't believe in God. They don't believe in supernatural possibilities. They don't believe in universal values, ideas like redemption, or good or evil as concepts that are real. These are good, decent, thoughtful, intelligent people. There's something about the way they were raised, the culture we live in, and the world in these times; these things are so deconstructed and have been so poorly modeled that they can't even believe in these larger ideas. We can't even begin to put a face on them like Jesus. We have to talk about these ideas and whether you could believe them. What I find is that Lost occupies that level of conversation. Do you even believe in things like redemption? What is redemption, really? Do you believe in something like good; do you believe in something like evil? Do you believe that these objective values actually even exist? Do you believe that all you are is just stuff? Are you supernatural and natural? Is there spirit in the world or are you a spiritual creature?

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Links to Your World—Special “Lost” Edition—Tuesday May 18

Welcome to the special Lost edition of “Links to Your World”! The 2-1/2 hour series finale is this Sunday, May 23.

The 23 “Get Anchored” posts that reference Lost.

 

‘Lost’: 13 Character Profiles. What did Locke do pre-crash? What happened to Sawyer on the Island? Where did Kate go in Sideways world? And more…

 

A good explanation of why so many like Lost—and some hints about the series finale.

 

I don’t recommend you try to jump into Lost if you haven’t been watching by now. But here’s how to try--

 

Other Links from this Week:

“Just hearing Mom's voice over the phone may have the same soothing effect as getting a hug in person, according to new research” (Time)

 

NYT: He went through the first 18 years of life as “(No Name) Pauson.”

 

A Primer on the Person and Work of the Holy Spirit.

 

Robot officiates at Japanese wedding. Maybe I should get one of these as a stand-in for weddings I want to avoid….

 

Previous posts at “Get Anchored” since last Tuesday:

Final Season of ‘Lost’ Promises to Make Fans More Annoying Than Ever

Lost: “If there’s one word that we keep coming back to, it’s redemption”

Song of the Week: The Prodigal

“The public praise and worship of God, even from children, has the power to cancel the assignment of evil spirits”

“Use the words ‘I’ or ‘me’ at least 12-15 times”

LeaderLines: Leading Change--Motivate the Elephant

“‘Awesome’ and ‘awful’ are actually closer to each other on the continuum of quality than either is to ‘meh’”

How People Really Decide If Their Church is Flourishing

Winning Ways: How to Strengthen a Sermon

Storytelling, Juggling, and Lost

Review of Stephen Prothero’s “God Is Not One”

Sunday, May 16, 2010

Lost: “If there’s one word that we keep coming back to, it’s redemption”

From a NYT interview with the Lost overseers:

Q. Your show traffics in a lot of big themes — fate versus free will, good versus evil, faith versus reason, how often Sawyer should be shirtless. Ultimately, what were the most important themes for you in this series?

DAMON LINDELOF: If there’s one word that we keep coming back to, it’s redemption. It is that idea of everybody has something to be redeemed for and the idea that that redemption doesn’t necessarily come from anywhere else other than internally. But in order to redeem yourself, you can only do it through a community. So the redemption theme started to kind of connect into “live together, die alone,” which is that these people were all lone wolves who were complete strangers on an aircraft, even the ones who were flying together like Sun and Jin. Then let’s bring them together and through their experiences together allow themselves to be redeemed.

It’s a shame they feel that “redemption doesn’t necessarily come from anywhere else other than internally”—quite the opposite of the Christian redemption story. But thumbs-up for the necessity of community in the search for redemption.

There’s more in the interview, including their acknowledgement that the show “is a mash-up/remix of our favorite stories, whether that’s Bible stories from Sunday school or ‘Narnia’ or ‘Star Wars’ or the writings of John Steinbeck.”

Thursday, May 13, 2010

“‘Awesome’ and ‘awful’ are actually closer to each other on the continuum of quality than either is to ‘meh’”

James Poniewozik, on taking creative risks:

You have to be willing to suck if you ever want to be great. "Awesome" and "awful" are actually closer to each other on the continuum of quality than either is to "meh."

If your first priority is creating something amazing, you will make some mind-blowingly awful mistakes. If your first priority is avoiding mistakes, you will preclude the possibility of succeeding wildly (and you may end up making mistakes anyway).

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Storytelling, Juggling, and Lost

"I always thought storytelling was like juggling. You keep a lot of different tales in the air, and juggle them up and down, and if you're good you don't drop any. So maybe juggling is a kind of storytelling, too."
--from Haroun and the Sea of Stories, by Salman Rushie, a book that influenced the Lost creators I'm told.

Let's see what kind of jugglers they are as Lost winds down to its last 3.5 hours...

Saturday, April 24, 2010

“The pain of being lost and the profound challenge of being found”

Jeff Jensen:

Lost is about finding meaning in a culture where meaning is hard to see and challenging to find. Lost is a show full of mystery, but I don't think finding ''the answers'' has ever been the point. I think the point has been to dramatize the usefulness of mystery. Lost shows us that mystery is an invitation to seek meaning in life. But it also shows us that you can get Lost in mystery, too. And the cost for those who do can be profound. It's about the perils and pitfalls of anyone who dares to seek meaning in such an age — and about the cost to anyone who dares to not seek meaning in life regardless of the age, and especially now. Lost is about the pain of being Lost and the profound challenge of being found. That's what I think Lost is about.

Wednesday, April 07, 2010

Lost: All You Need is Love

James Poniewozik:

Both Charlie and Desmond are awakened to another plane of existence by recalling someone they loved [on the island]. If that's too corny for you, sorry. I like this idea: here, "love at first sight" is not just fate, but a flash of awareness of a life that you are meant to have. It is, literally, a moment of clarity, in which you see beyond the confines of time and space. If that's corny, it works for me--not just emotionally but in terms of Lost's alt-universe story.

Thursday, April 01, 2010

Lost: Biblical Allusions or Illusions?

Lost fans, take a look at Chris Seay’s thoughts about biblical allusions in Lost characters and plot lines.  He’s written a book called The Gospel According to Lost. I’m not sure I entirely agree with his take, but its worth a read.  Find it at USA Today’s post, “It's Sunday school on Tuesday night for 'Lost' devotees.”

As I’ve written before, my guess is that Lost will end as a good story that falls short of the Good Story. But we have a couple of more months of plot twists to go, hmm?

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Lost: “There must be some way to earn forgiveness”

Nancy Guthrie:

In this week’s episode [of Lost], a character who accidentally killed a man bowed before a priest before being put to death. But the priest refused to absolve him of his sin.

“There must be some way to earn forgiveness,” he said.

This scene captures the desperate cry of all those who have done wrong. “There must be something I can do! There must be some way I can earn the pardon of God not only for what I’ve done, but for who I am!”

Perhaps the answer in the gospel might seem, at first, as harsh as that of the priest in the drama who says there is not enough time to do penance. Because the gospel says, “No, there is no way you can earn forgiveness. Your debt is impossible to pay.” But into this hopeless situation Jesus steps in and says, “I will pay. I will earn your forgiveness by my own sinless life and through my own sacrificial death. I will provide for you the forgiveness you do not deserve and cannot earn.”

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Lost: Black and White

Last night’s episode of Lost should put to rest those who’ve been thinking of Jacob as some sort of Christ-figure. Yes, you could say he “baptized” Richard in the ocean in the process of calling him to be his representative. Yes, he exists to “contain” evil like cork in a bottle. Yes, his opponent (the Smoke Monster) is a liar and a murderer. But you’ll miss the religious backstory of Lost if you try to interpret in terms of the Christian worldview. As I’ve said before, there’s a yin-yang thing going here.

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Lost: Making the Reading List

Seth Stevenson:

Lost throws so many book covers up on-screen…that they almost serve as a bibliography, signaling the series' broad themes and interests. The stream of author shout-outs also seems like a quick and painless way for a TV show to advertise its literary gravitas. Lost is like that guy who purposely leaves his copy of Beloved out on the coffee table for when he brings home a date.

Gotta love that last line.

Go ahead: name the books you’ve read or plan to read because you wanted to know why they tied in to the Lost story.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Lost: “Nothing’s Irreversible”

Doc Jensen at EW often spins away into thin speculation when writing about Lost, but he’s fun to read anyway. Here are his ramblings regarding Lost’s allusions to C.S. Lewis:

I'd like to...bring in our old dead Christian author friend, Clive Staples (C.S.) Lewis, whom Lost has cited via our dead red-headed Freighter friend, Charlotte Staples Lewis. C.S. Lewis wrote a great many books that thematically mirror Lost. Besides the Chronicles of Narnia, The Screwtape Letters, and The Space Trilogy, there's The Pilgrim's Regress, an allegory about spiritual development involving a man who as a child has a vision of an island that can bring spiritual fulfillment and human purpose. As an adult, he goes on a journey to find the island, only to discover two things: (1) the island is embodied by a person; and (2) The road to the island leads back home. And then there is this:

The Great Divorce

The Great Divorce was Lewis' sorta-kinda response/rebuttal to Dante's Inferno and especially William Blake's The Marriage of Heaven and Hell. But Lewis' vision of Heaven actually functions as an allegory for how life should be lived in the here and now. Lewis has two big points to make with the book. The first: We can either view the world we live in as an upward slope leading to heaven, or a downward slope leading to hell. The second: As long as we draw breath, there is always time to reverse course. Now here's where the applications to Lost get really interesting:

In his introduction to the book, Lewis (who preferred that his friends call him Jack) tackled the question that's at the center of Lost: How do we ''fix'' ourselves? …His answer:

''I do not think that all those who choose wrong roads perish; but their rescue consists of being put back on the right road. A sum can be put right: but only by going back till you find the error and working it afresh from that point, never by simply going on. Evil can be undone, but it cannot 'develop' into good. Time does not heal it. The spell must be unwound, bit-by-bit, with 'backwards mutters of dissevering power' — or else not. It is still 'either-or.' If we insist on keeping Hell (or even Earth), we shall not see Heaven: if we accept Heaven we shall not be able to retain the smallest and most intimate souvenirs of Hell.''

…

Application to Lost:

Jack was right in ''LA X'' when he said, ''Nothing's irreversible.'' But healing change does not come from blowing up the past….Stop running away! Stop ''simply going on,'' because it will never ''develop into good,'' and ''time does not heal it.'' And then, once we've dealt with it, we need to bring in the words that Rose gave us in ''LA X'': We need to ''let it go'' and move on. Leave our ''souvenirs of Hell'' behind and move into the fullness of life, and then what lies beyond.

Jensen also speculates that the Lost creators may be playing off an unfinished story of Lewis's called The Dark Tower, published about 14 years after his death (and, not to be confused with the Stephen King series by the same name):

Lewis' The Dark Tower begins with a conversation about time travel. The characters conclude that the past can't be changed. They then find a device called a ''chronoscope'' that allows them to peer into the past or future — or so they think. Looking into the chronoscope, they witness a past or future world (they can't tell which, so they just call it ''Othertime'') in which a devilish character leads people astray, clouding their minds and turning them into virtual zombies. Then a character makes a discovery: The chronoscope isn't a device that allows peeks into other times — it allows them to peek into parallel worlds. He then makes another discovery: His double in Othertime is a bad guy. To prevent him from doing bad things, he crosses over...and accidentally switches minds with his bad doppelganger. And so, while the Good Guy tries to save the day in Othertime, his evil doppelganger wreaks havoc in ''the real world'' and the Good Guy's ''real world'' friends try to stop him.

...

C.S. Lewis technically never finished the story. The Dark Tower only exists as a fragment of a novel, an unfinished work — a Lost story....Part of me is in love with the idea that those Stephen King-loving, Star Wars-grooving writers of Lost are basically taking the raw material of Lewis' Dark Tower and building something new out of it. At the very least, I find myself wondering if Jack made the same mistake in ''Lighthouse'' that the characters in The Dark Tower made about the chronoscope: those mirrors inside the Lighthouse didn't peek into the past — they peeked into the Sideways World.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Lost: The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come?

Seth Stevenson on Lost:

“Perhaps the island is like Dickens' Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come, forcing the characters to take a long, hard look at their own weaknesses and failings. Just as Scrooge did, we viewers wonder: "Are these the shadows of the things that will be, or are they shadows of things that may be, only?"

Wednesday, March 03, 2010

Lost: A good story that will fall short of the Good Story?

Jeff Jensen is seein’ what I’m seein’ in Lost’s Jacob-unLocke storyline—an unfolding Yin/Yang view of the Island:

Jacob isn't ''good,'' per se — he's just capable of giving life. Put another way: Jacob is the god of beginnings. He is The Alpha. The Man in Black? Not evil — he's the god of endings. He is the Omega. The beginning and the end. Polar, warring opposites, but absolutely necessary for life to bloom (Alpha) and to have form (Omega). Both are necessary for anything to have meaning. Jacob unchecked leads to chaos; Man In Black unchecked leads to annihilation. Both need to exist in balance; both need to be equally weighted rocks on the scale.

Jensen may be premature on his assessment. After all, we’ve only seen the Man in Black unchecked and how that leads to annihilation; we haven’t seen Jacob “unchecked” yet so we don’t know if such a state would lead to chaos.

I tend to think Jensen is getting this right, though (with the caveat that the writers are famous for misdirection). And if he’s right, then Lost will end up being at best a good story but not the Good Story. In the Good Story of Christianity, good and evil are not in balance as warring-but-equal opposites. Satan is not God’s dark counterpart in an unending cycle of existence. Instead, evil is an aberrant intrusion into God’s world, and will be destroyed in the final act of the Bible’s linear drama.

(By the way, stories that track with the Good Story celebrate this truth. There is no “balance of powers" in Narnia: Jadis the White Witch loses to Aslan. There are no eternally-existent polar opposites in Middle Earth: Sauron is snuffed out when the Ring of Power is destroyed.)

It will be interesting to see if Lost tracks with the Good Story or simply ends as nothing more than a good story.

Tuesday, March 02, 2010

Lost: What to Make of Jacob and non-Locke

For all you Losties, what do you make of the identity of Jacob and the non-Locke, the “Man in Black”?  I’m thinking there’s a Yin/Yang thing going here, but the writers are (in)famous for misdirection.

Doc Jensen:

Consider again the scene in ''Lighthouse'' in which Jack picked up The Annotated Alice. ''I used to read this to you when you were little,'' Jack said, waxing nostalgic. ''You always wanted to hear about Kitty and Snowdrop, they were Alice's...'' But Jack never finished his sentence because his angry adolescent huffed out on him. This was a really conspicuous choice, and I remember thinking that I should really follow up on it and investigate what Lost had decided to leave unsaid.

…

What Jack wasn't allowed to say was that Kitty and Snowdrop were Alice's kittens. And if David had stuck around and engaged his father in literary exegesis about the book, they may have together noted the following detail, which should blow up any self-respecting crazy Lost theorist's brain:

One kitten is black, and one kitten is white. One is bad; one is good. Kitty's the black one; Snowdrop's the white one. Kitty's the bad one; Snowdrop, the good one. Think: black and white rocks in The Caves; think: the black and white stones in The Cave of Names; think: Man in Black and Jacob; think: John Locke's backgammon story. ''Two players. One black. One white.''

…

Perhaps in the story of Lost, Jacob is…taking the raw material of castaway lives and desires and redeeming it with shape, purpose, and future. Or at least, he is trying to. After all, these characters do have free will, and they can choose to use it to produce a quality of life that's beyond salvaging.

As they say, stay tuned…

Monday, February 08, 2010

"What's The Use of Stories That Aren't Even True?"

Okay, I'm a geeky sucker for sticking with Lost across 5, now 6, seasons. Then again, what other TV show gets people talking about such important subjects? Case in point, from Entertainment Weekly:

Desmond Hume reads the darndest books. When we first met him in season 2, the moony marooner ran off into the jungle carrying a copy of The Third Policeman, a perversely playful work with a twisted plot that mirrors the most despairing of Lost theories: that our fallen castaways are stuck in an eternal cycle of damnation, their looping hell managed by morally ambiguous enforcers. In ''LA X,'' [the opener for Season 6] Desmond was reading Rushdie's Haroun And The Sea of Stories. Like Policeman, Haroun functions as commentary and critique on storytelling, but otherwise couldn't be more different. The plot concerns a boy who all but curses his father in a moment of despair by saying, cynically, ''What's the use of stories that aren't even true?'' As a consequence, the father becomes heartbroken, and loses his storytelling mojo. Haroun then embarks on a fantastic adventure to save the enchanted ''Ocean of the Steam of Story'' from villains who would corrupt it. By taking that journey and saving that enchanted place, Haroun restores his father's life and power by giving him the tale of his own adventure, which, when told, rouses a hopeless town to rebel against exploitive, oppressive forces. What might Haroun have to say to us about season 6? Mostly, I'm thinking of Jack and his relationship to his father. But more than anything, I'm fascinated by Desmond's progression from the surreal cynicism of Policeman to the redemptive fable of Haroun. I've certainly seen a lot of Policeman in Lost. In season 6, perhaps we'll see more Haroun.

Thanks to Lost, I already have Flannery O'Conner's Everything That Rises Must Converge on my Amazon Wish List. Now I've added Haroun as well. Hopeless, hopeless geek.